Bidaah vs. Innovation

July 27, 2008

Mutawaa – Form “vs” Substance

Filed under: The "Magic" Kingdom — Tags: , , , , — bidaah @ 6:35 pm

Over at Naeem’s blog, brother Naeem has an excellent post about the Mutawaa “Choosing Form over substance.” The implementation of the so-called religious police in the Magic Kingdom is not what Islam has prescribed but rather its more in line with a Fascist state. Those who advocate the implementation of the religious police should ponder the fact that so many Saudis actually have the opposite reaction to the state sanctioned sanctions. Islam lies in the heart not in the stick. The following excerpt from the post is a very enlightening.

And even if the Mutawwa were to succeed in covering every woman and forcing every man to pray, then what? Would that magically transform Saudi society into an Islamic utopia? All this obsession with the outer forms while ignoring the internal states is pure folly and doomed to failure.

The Prophet (saw) was sent with the primary mission to perfect akhlaq (moral character, etiquettes) – a lofty goal that can never be accomplished with superficial tactics of forcing people to pray and cover. The proper way is to focus on the hearts and attract people to the balanced teachings of our beloved Prophet (saw).

July 5, 2008

Bidaah vs. Innovation is back!

Filed under: Uncategorized — Tags: , , , , , — bidaah @ 2:56 pm

I started this blog a little over two year ago but after a couple of months or so I stopped blogging. There were a number of reasons for this. The salafi tide seemed to recede in USA and things seemed to be getting better and I also got busy with other projects etc. In recent months events in the real and the virtual world have prompted me to come back to the blogging scene and so I am announcing my return to the blogging scene. Insha’Allah the news posts will be very innovative. :) There are also new bloggers since last year who have discussed this issue – The story of Salafi Burnout comes to mind. As always Tariq Nelson’s post have been enlightening on this subject. One of the things that I like about brother Tariq is that his posts are about the real world and they discuss real problems. The funny and yet sad thing is that wackos out there who think that we should not help other people in need.

P.S: I am also thinking about a new catchier name for the blog. Do people have any suggestions?

Blog at WordPress.com.